The Quilt - Poetry in Color Forum
 


Poetry in Color Forum
Donation Goal For Private Hosting 2009
Help us get better hosting = make your donation today!
We Have Received $160 Towards Our Goal Of $750
21.33% Of Our Goal Has Been Reached




Welcome To The JPiC Community.





All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:37 AM.
Official Forum Language Is English. Translate Below:
Click Here To Join JPiC Forum.

Kewl Stuff JPiC Radio Daily Horoscope JPiC Arcade Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
    JPiC Portal » Main Forum Index » Poetic Colours » The Critique Saloon

The Critique Saloon This is the place to post poems that you'd like to better by getting suggestions & constructive criticism. **NOTE** For formal critique only!

The Quilt
this thread has 3 replies and has been viewed 846 times


Post New Thread  Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 08-08-2006, 11:14 PM
  post #1
Email Address Update Needed

J. Marie's Avatar

J. Marie Is The Original Thread Starter
Real Name: Janie
Last Online: 02-17-2007 12:00 AM
Location: Wisconsin
A/S/L:
Join Date: Aug 6 2006
Posts: 29 Threads: 16
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Biography: Orginally from the Chicago area.
J. Marie has not received any JPiC Member Awards.
J. Marie has not championed any arcade games.
Instant Message Info Is Private.
The Quilt

(This is one of my first poems written, I know it could use some polishing up but to painful to re-write..still would love an honest opinion)Thanks


Need to let go of the guilt like the stitching on a quilt.
Unravel each thread, one at a time, until I unwind.

The quilt of guilt started long ago, by an overbearing mother, who I thought understood. I only dug myself deeper with trust put in her.
I only added more stitching to the quilt.
Unknowingly adding more guilt.

My mother I thought was my friend, turned her back on me with all my pleas. I needed her, needed her trust, she was always hard to please
when it came to me.
Should of known better, I blame me.

Reaching out for understanding and unconditional love the way a mother I thought should love. How wrong I was!
I tried to reach out, finding only coldness on her part, torturing my heart.
Hearing the phone slam down, she hung up.
One to many times she’s done this to me.
Why do I bother? It only adds more guilt on me.

I did nothing wrong, I assumed she understood. She never gave us a chance. A chance to rekindle our love, our friendship. She only added more threads to the quilt. Leaving me feel the pain and the guilt.

So many misunderstanding’s she’ll never know. I only tried to be a good daughter and put trust in her soul.

So I sit here and cry trying to unravel these stitches pulled tight. Stitches of sorrow, stitches of lost tomorrows, stitches of distress that need to be addressed.....to go on with my life with no guilt inside.
J. Marie is offline   Reply With Quote
JPiC Forum Sponsor Links • This Forum is enhanced with content-revelevant advertisings...
JPiC Whole-Post Ad Policy
Whole-Post advertisings are shown only to JPiC Forum For Writers' Guests. Once successfully registered, such ads will not be shown. CLICK HERE to register your 100% FREE JPiC account today and become an active Member of our Community for Poets & Writers! CLICK HERE for advertising opportunities.

Old 08-09-2006, 12:34 PM
  post #2
Email Address Update Needed

Tiel Aisha Ansari's Avatar

Last Online: 08-14-2006 12:35 PM
A/S/L:
Join Date: Aug 7 2006
Posts: 13 Threads: 5
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Tiel Aisha Ansari has not received any JPiC Member Awards.
Tiel Aisha Ansari has not championed any arcade games.
Instant Message Info Is Private.
J. Marie-- I can understand why this is painful. You're very brave to write about it, and especially to post it in front of a whole crowd of strangers.

Compared to "Escape"-- which seems to address some of the same things-- I think this is a stronger poem. Because you have used a unifying metaphor (the quilt), rather than simply stating facts/feelings: to me this is an important part of poetry. Also the sound-relationship between "quilt" and "guilt" helps the poem.

If you were to change anything... the stanza that starts "Reaching out..." seems longer than necessary. I might drop the first line and start it with "I tried to reach out..." Also you have "I thought she understood" and "I assumed she understood" at different points in the poem, I'd restate one of those (maybe try "see" or "know" instead of understand) or drop altogether.

I hope the future holds better things for you. God bless.
Tiel Aisha Ansari is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-09-2006, 12:44 PM
  post #3
Email Address Update Needed

J. Marie's Avatar

J. Marie Is The Original Thread Starter
Real Name: Janie
Last Online: 02-17-2007 12:00 AM
Location: Wisconsin
A/S/L:
Join Date: Aug 6 2006
Posts: 29 Threads: 16
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Biography: Orginally from the Chicago area.
J. Marie has not received any JPiC Member Awards.
J. Marie has not championed any arcade games.
Instant Message Info Is Private.
Tiel, thanks so much for your reply. I appreciate it. This is an on going issue with my mother....I love her dearly but she never seems to quite understand me. I am going thru a very difficult time right now which I hope the words come to write about..

Thank you so much for your suggestions...who knows I may revise it one day.
J. Marie
J. Marie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-14-2006, 10:37 AM
  post #4
JPiC Senior Moderator Extraordinaire

PaintedDiary's Avatar

My Mood:
Real Name: Kimberley D. Robinson
Last Online: Yesterday 05:33 PM
Location: PA
A/S/L: 45
Join Date: Jun 23 2006
Posts: 4,472 Threads: 261
Member Blog Entries: 2
Thanks: 167
Thanked 22 Times in 14 Posts
Biography: Teachers, like candles; consume a little of ourselves everyday, so our students can shine bright.
Surfs The Web With:
Awards Showcase
Contest Winner Award Titanium Friend Award Critique Extraordinaire Award Artistic Award Contributor Award #2 Hall Of Fame Contributor Award 
Total Awards: 7
PaintedDiary has not championed any arcade games.
Instant Message Info Is Private.
Dear J. Marie,

First and foremost, I am sorry to read this experience. I can only imagine, how this has played a part in your life, and weighs on your heart.......
My writing will be in blue, for an easier read.


Quote:
Originally Posted by J. Marie
(This is one of my first poems written, I know it could use some polishing up but to painful to re-write..still would love an honest opinion)Thanks

My heart goes out to you.

I will attempt to critique, piece by piece, and is only my opinion, and are merely suggestions. As a proem......Please do revise to YOUR liking, and what feels comfortable for you. What we say that may read better, is how we would like for it to read (how we like it), and it is your poem....I also advise to wait for an "Expert" and "Professional" critque from Ms Jacquii. What I appreciate most about this, is the fact that, this unedited version, with this type of content, is usualy very strong, raw, real, and rarely needs major revisions, simple minor adjustments. {IMO = In My Opinion}. With that said...


Need to let go of the guilt like the stitching on a quilt.
Unravel each thread, one at a time, until I unwind.

IMO, the first line is SO POWERFUL, that can stand alone. However, I understand your extention...cuz this is how you feel, and you would indeed unwind from this type of experience, because you are going throught it, not I, or anyone else, so I understand.

The quilt of guilt started long ago, by an overbearing mother, who I thought understood. I only dug myself deeper with trust put in her.
I only added more stitching to the quilt.
Unknowingly adding more guilt.

The following lines are again {SO POWERFUL} J.Marie...

I only added more stitching to the quilt.
Unknowingly adding more guilt.


I would like to see this power, this expresion of your hurt, weaved within this poem, your quilt. I would like to see it perhaps one or two more times, within the poem. To me will add richness, and rsymbolize repetativeness, just like the pain. But with saying a couple of times, you are taking ownership for these lines, and get stronger, each time.


My mother I thought was my friend, turned her back on me with all my pleas. I needed her, needed her trust, she was always hard to please
when it came to me.
Should of known better, I blame me.

Here, was different for me, as I never thought of my Mother as my friend, and I see, you did. So, here is one of those times that different backgrounds come into play, when critiquing, if one chooses to voice their opinion, even with the divergence. The stanza, as a whole, is part of the hurt, you are quilting, that you are also building in the story.

Reaching out for understanding and unconditional love the way a mother I thought should love. How wrong I was!
I tried to reach out, finding only coldness on her part, torturing my heart.
Hearing the phone slam down, she hung up.
One to many times she’s done this to me.
Why do I bother? It only adds more guilt on me.

Here, the layering, gets more intricate, with more emotion. The catayst for the anger is already there. Now, you are actually, going more in depth with your pain. I am so sorry, as I can only imagine, how writing this was extremely emotional for you. Perhaps, you experience in a small way, that writing this was a small dose of healing for you.

I did nothing wrong, I assumed she understood. She never gave us a chance. A chance to rekindle our love, our friendship. She only added more threads to the quilt. Leaving me feel the pain and the guilt.


Here is one of those times where those "POWER LINES", can be reused to reinforce the pain, the emotion, and so on..)(Instead of "I", perhaps, use the "She") SHE only added more stitching to the quilt. Unknowingly adding more guilt), instead of...(She only added more threads to the quilt. Leaving me feel the pain and the guilt). Just a suggestion.

Perhaps playing with those words "assumed she understood", may lead to something a tad bit stronger, since, you are in the hottest zone of the poem, here, with the layered emotion at a pinnacle..


So many misunderstanding’s she’ll never know. I only tried to be a good daughter and put trust in her soul.

Again, here, may what to play with the word choice..."So many misunderstanding's".......

So I sit here and cry trying to unravel these stitches pulled tight. Stitches of sorrow, stitches of lost tomorrows, stitches of distress that need to be addressed.....to go on with my life with no guilt inside.
The last stanza is how this means to end, so powerful!

Thank you for sharing this, as it must have been very difficult, as I have mentioned. Take Care and God Bless J. Marie.

Painted Diary aka Kimberly



Signed By PaintedDiary


Forum Signatures Are Not Shown To Unregistered Guests.
CLICK HERE to Register Your Free JPiC Forum Account.

PaintedDiary is offline   Reply With Quote
Please Visit These JPiC Forum Sponsors.
The Language of Poetry FormsFanStory.comAllPoetryVids.com
Post New Thread  Reply

  JPiC Portal » Main Forum Index » Poetic Colours » The Critique Saloon



Additional Options
Bookmarks

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Twisted Fate, Hearts Rapture Patricia_Lynn Inspiring Novelists 4 11-14-2006 11:24 AM

Page generated in 0.27184 seconds with 21 queries

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15