Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please - Poetry in Color Forum
Register Members List JPiC Blogs Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read JPiC Newsletter

Go Back   Poetry in Color Forum > Poetic Colours > The Critique Saloon > Revisions
JPiC Forum Chatbox
Chatbox Disabled For Your Usergroup...
* You must be logged in to view and use the JPiC Chatbox!
Recent JPiC Forum Posts
Newest Announcements/Admin Notes
 

Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please

Thread Information: This thread has 4 replies and has been viewed 1339 times
 
Social Bookmarks Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 08-18-2006, 10:36 AM   #1 (permalink)
Newbie
J. Marie's Avatar
Name: Janie
Last Online:
02-16-2007 11:00 PM
Default Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please J. Marie Started This Thread
Stolen Moments (Revised)

Forever I will treasure the
times we share together.

Hidden moments of passion,
time moves too quickly.
Wanting to stop the clock, never
letting go of this forbidden
passion we share.

Far and few in between those
hours bring such meaning to me.

The strength of your arms
create a feeling of safety, security.
Your soothing touch calms each
vibration that runs through my body.

Releasing tension, melting my heart,
my soul. I find it difficult to
let go of this desire we share,
that should not be.

Wrapped up in the moment,
feelings grow deeper. Never
thought it would be you
who moves me so.

Holding back my inhibitions some
for you don’t belong to me.
You belong to another.

Right now, I will be happy to linger.
Secretly wishing you were mine.

I will always cherish this point in time
when you were mine.
If even for only a few hours at a time!
Last edited by J. Marie; 08-18-2006 at 10:31 PM.
 

Old 08-18-2006, 10:23 PM   #2 (permalink)
JPiC Senior Moderator Extraordinaire
PaintedDiary's Avatar
Name: Kimberly
Gender: Female
Location: Channeling Rainbow
PaintedDiary's Mood:
Last Online:
Yesterday 11:17 PM
Default Re: Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please
Hi J. Marie,

This is a wonderful write J. Marie. A sure winner in my opinion. The revisions look great as well. A little provacative, hot, sexy spice.....is always nice! , LOL!!! I have only "three" miniscule suggestions, and "two" major (check for publication type things), and not suggestions. Having said that, here I go...

1} Ms Tree mentioned this, and I did not catch it....and that is the (to, too) choice. This should read....

***time moves too quickly

2} Perhaps there should be a comma or elipses after the word share in the following stanza...

Releasing tension, melting my heart,
my soul. I find it difficult to
let go of this desire we share
that should not be.

3} I believe the contraction should be written out to read (do not), as opposed to don't. However, another publishing preference type question to ask Ms Jacquii and / or other published Authors.

4} Lastly, this poem consists of.....29 lines. Again something to check with Ms Jacquii, FaSha and / or other published Authors of this genre as to publisher's preferences
(in terms of number of lines).

***There may be a publisher's limit (for this genre) , I am not sure, however, a question to consider.***

That was a joy to critique J. Marie, and thank you for submitting such a beautiful piece for us to lay our eyes on! Take Care,

Kim


Never, Never____ Stop Painting Your Diary!!




 

Old 08-18-2006, 10:34 PM   #3 (permalink)
Newbie
J. Marie's Avatar
Name: Janie
Last Online:
02-16-2007 11:00 PM
Default Re: Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please J. Marie Started This Thread
Thank you so much..you are so sweet. I did make some minor changes after I read your reply. I should pull out my ol college book, the Harbrace book on puncuation.....that would probably help. Always did get confused with the two to's...LOL

I will ask for opinions from the ones who have been published when I have more time..for it is getting late.....

BTW did u check out "My Dream"......Thanks again I really appreciate it.
J. Marie
 

Old 08-20-2006, 09:41 AM   #4 (permalink)
Miss Understood
MsJacquiiC's Avatar
Name: Jacquii Cooke
Gender: Female
Location: In a cloud of smoke.
MsJacquiiC's Mood:
Last Online:
Yesterday 06:05 PM
Default Re: Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please
Hey J. MARIE - I really like this revision more than the original - such is the beauty of the tweaking process ----> I also love the theme of this poem, as it sounds like a bit of my life actually.

I do have some suggestions for you, and I totally agree with what MS PAINTED & MS TREE have suggested about the "spice it up a bit" I, as a writer & poet, LOVE to see flamboyant and pretentious words. The longer, the better LOL - I'd actually like to see this poem with a bit of attitude - right from the beginning:

Forever I will treasure the
those utterly heartbreaking
times we share together
in our nest of sacred longings...

----------- ALSO - watch the context of your words... I will treasure....... Times we shared ------> very important that the tense remains congruent throughout, until the ending stanzas...


Hidden moments of passion,
time moves too quickly.

------------ This line seems incomplete to me, kinda like a thought that never quite finished... Perhaps some flourishing will complete the thought. example:

Those moments: so passion-laden.
Time moves too quickly by...

OR PUNCTUATION:

Hidden moments of passion.
Time moves too quickly.
----

The strength of your arms
create a feeling of safety, security.

Same as above about the verb-tense...

The strength of you arms
creates a feeling....

ALSO here - You may consider adding a bit more spice to your words. What do you think of when you think "safety" or "security"? I think of a net. example:

The strength in your muscled arms
creates the net I long to call home....


I also notice that you've began a lot of your stanzas with a verb in the act of doing something, i.e. Wanting, Holding, Releasing:

Releasing tension, melting my heart,
my soul. I find it difficult to......

I think this is a big NO-NO - Sometimes it may work, but I don't think it works in this piece at all... What you may want to do instead is to add an action "scene" instead of the descriptive. You may even consider combining your stanzas, as there is no set guideline, i.e.

The strength of your arms
create a feeling of safety, security.
Your soothing touch calms each
vibration that runs through my body.

Releasing tension, melting my heart,
my soul. I find it difficult to
let go of this desire we share,
that should not be.

BECOMES

The strength in your muscled arms
creates the net I long to call home.
Your soothing touch calms each
vibration that runs through my body,
releasing tention. Melting my heart,
my soul.... I find it difficult to
let go of this desire we share.
The one that shouldn't be.

Again - I think you have the premise started for a publishable poem - It's just a matter of tweaking it and editing it and revising it that will make it publishable, rather than "just another poem." Now that I've re-read this poem a couple of times, the premise is very good actually.

I have a suggestion for your next revision: try reading your poem aloud to yourself. If it sounds right - write it down the way you've said it... You may find that the linebreaks are a little different, but I think you will also find out that the speakable poem is more than likely the better version.

So anyway - I hope that makes sense - AND I look forward to your next revision. Again - if you have any questions then PM me and we'll try to figure it out OK - Thanx again for sharing also - I'm kinda liking this piece!

Jacquii.



“I do use powerful words to evoke emotion, but also to stimulate imagination. If one can 'see' the words dance before
his eyes - then he can likely feel, smell and even taste them as well. And I do thoroughly enjoy really tasty poems.
My poetry is an emotions-fest sprinkled with a little garlic salt, Mrs. Dash, fresh ginger and Tabasco sauce...
My poetry is like a piece of General Tso's chicken tossed in ghetto soul.” ---
MsJacquiiC



JacquiiCooke.com | Poetica Magnifique
Professional Web & Graphic Design Services
GreetingsGalleryOnline | Beautifully Free e-Cards


You REALLY Like Us? ==> Support JPiC with a donation or Purchase a premium membership

 

Old 12-11-2006, 06:57 PM   #5 (permalink)
Name: Nikos Tselepides
Last Online:
04-27-2008 01:13 PM
Default Re: Stolen Moments (revised) Yikes critique please
I finally discovered the "critique' place.

A good poem in general.

The lines that end with the words "the" and "each" are wrong-ended.
At the end of a line, always use a word which contains a unit of meaning, and never one which has no meaning in itself unless connected with another word.
Also the comment that says never begin with a gerundival verb (Having, Doing etc--the _ING form of the verb) finds me in agreement.

Thanks for a nice poem.
 


JPiC Portal > Main Forum Index > Poetic Colours > The Critique Saloon > Revisions

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off



Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Stolen Moments (critique me please) J. Marie The Critique Saloon 3 08-18-2006 12:21 AM
Navigation
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:20 PM.
GreetingsGalleryOnline.com

Powered by vBulletin® gets JPiCans scribing.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Some Custom Pages Using vBAdvanced CMPS